The Job I Didn’t Take

The Infinite Game, Part 1: What It Costs To Stay True to Your Why

When I finished my executive MBA, my mother called with a very reasonable question.

“So,” she said, “does this mean you’ll get promoted now?”

I told her no. Getting an MBA doesn’t guarantee a promotion. Besides, I hadn’t done it for that. I did it because I wanted to understand business well enough to lead within it. I wanted to learn more about strategy, marketing, and finance.

My mother’s question made sense. Most of us are taught to see careers this way: you do the work, you get the reward — promotion, title, raise. That’s how such games work. You play, you win, and then it’s over.

But not everything in life works like that. I learned this years before my MBA, even if I didn’t have the words for it then.

The Business I Shut Down

I left a hospital leadership job to start my own small practice, focusing on a tough condition to treat. To keep things steady while I built it, I also took a part-time job running a treatment program.

Our second child arrived barely a year into the adventure.

By then, I was commuting nearly three hours a day, shuttling between the program, my practice, and home. I was exhausted in a way that coffee couldn’t fix.

Two years in, I shut the practice down.

I’ll be honest: exhaustion and money made the decision easier. But they weren’t the reason. The reason was simple. Being an available father and husband mattered more to me than owning a successful practice.

Closing the practice cut my commute by a third. It also took away the unique stress of being a new business owner, which I hadn’t realized was a full-time job in itself.

For years after, I wondered what might have happened if my timing had been better. I replayed it the way Phil Connors replays February 2nd in Groundhog Day, tweaking the day to see if it might end differently.

Then I started my MBA, and it felt like my past decisions were being graded.

Strategy? I didn’t have one. Who was my practice for, and why would they pick me? Marketing? Not really. Referral relationships, patient experience, pricing, cash flow, operations? Weak, weak, weak, weak, and weak.

One good thing about psychiatry is that you can start a practice with very little money. The risk is that you can also do it without a solid business plan. I had a license and a good idea, but no real business.

So the “bad timing” I regretted for years turned out to be the luckiest thing that happened to me. If my timing had been better, who knows how much more — money and time — I would have wasted before learning what my professors taught me in one semester of my MBA. Inadvertently, our newborn became my best strategic advisor.

In his book The Infinite Game, Simon Sinek has a name for the willingness to make a costly change to advance a bigger purpose: existential flexibility. When I shut my practice down, it didn’t feel like a principle. It simply felt like failure.

The Interview That Ended Early

Years later, I interviewed for a Chief Medical Officer job. On paper, it was the kind of job everyone says you should want.

About fifteen minutes before the interview was supposed to end, the division president stopped it.

“You’re an excellent fit for this position,” he said.

That felt great, as it should. It’s the reward you expect in a finite game: you do the work, say the right things, and win.

Then he said the job required a monthly leadership meeting at his office — four nights away from home every month.

By then, having lost my wife, I was a solo dad to a preteen and a teenager. I told him I couldn’t commit to that. I wanted to be home for the ordinary nights. Dinner. Homework. Unplanned talks. The stuff that doesn’t look like much until you’re not there.

I didn’t get the job.

My practice decision got a verdict. A business school professor, in effect, told me I’d been lucky. This one never has. I still don’t know, by any measure that shows up on a resume, whether I made the right call.

Knowing Your Why Isn’t the Hard Part

If you’ve figured out your Why, as Sinek puts it, you might think the hard part is done. You know what motivates you, so decisions should be easier.

They don’t.

Knowing your Why doesn’t make acting on it easy. The real test isn’t finding your purpose. It’s what you do the day someone offers you something valuable to set it aside.

Sinek took his Infinite Game frame for this from the late James Carse, whose 1986 book Finite and Infinite Games opens like this:

“There are at least two kinds of games. One could be called finite, the other infinite. A finite game is played for the purpose of winning, an infinite game for the purpose of continuing the play.”

A career focused on winning is a finite game — the next title, the next line on your CV. Eventually, every hot streak ends. Everyone loses. But a career built around a bigger cause is an infinite game. There’s no final win, just staying in the game on your own terms for as long as you can.

Carse points out something important: finite games can exist within infinite ones. My practice was a finite game. It had customers, a strategy (or should have), and a bottom line, and it deserved to be played well. But it was part of a bigger game, and when the two conflicted, the bigger one won. The skills an MBA teaches matter. You just need to know which game they support.

Why This Matters More Now

When the practice was mine, the rules were mine. I set the hours and the pace. I could weigh my practice goals against my purpose, and when they clashed, I could shut the practice down.

Most physicians no longer have that lever. The AMA’s 2024 survey found that the share of physicians who own or co-own their practice fell from 53.2% in 2012 to 35.4% in 2024.

Ownership has its costs. I paid them. Until I decided not to. But switching from owner to employee changes the game. Someone else hands you the scoreboard: productivity numbers and patient satisfaction targets. Those are finite games, and they deserve to be played well. They’re just easy to mistake for the whole game.

As an owner, you can decide how to protect your Why. When you’re an employee, naming your Why becomes even more important because protecting it is no longer only in your hands.

The One Practice

Somewhere in your life right now, at work or at home, there’s a travel requirement. Or another demand. A trade that looks like winning by every conventional measure, but costs you something you don’t want to give up.

Name it before someone offers it. Finish these two sentences, in writing, this week:

“If I’m ever asked to ______, I’ll say no, because ______.”

“If what I’m building starts costing me ______, I’ll stop.”

Write it down now, before you feel pressured to say yes. Deciding ahead of time is easier than deciding in the moment.

I already know what I said. I’m still not sure it was the winning move. I just know it was mine.


This is Part 1 of a two-part series on the infinite game. Return next week for Part 2.

What are your thoughts on this?