The Hardest Agenda Item Should Come First
Last week, The New York Times ran a unique article. An obituary writer described how their team reports suicide.
For most of the last century, newspapers did one of two things. They either hid it with expressions like “died suddenly,” or sensationalized it with judgmental headlines.
Today, NYT does something different. When they know a death was a suicide, they say so plainly. They don’t guess at a reason. They don’t describe methods. They don’t say “committed,” a word that belongs to crimes.
When I read it, I realized that everywhere I trained used the first approach. As did most places where I worked.
But one place I worked was different.
The Silence Nobody Chose
If you’ve worked in medicine long enough, you know how this goes.
A patient dies by suicide. Word moves through the building in whispers.
“Did you hear about Dr. M’s patient?”
“Yeah. Awful.”
“Is she okay?”
“I don’t know. I didn’t want to bring it up.”
Plenty of places review the case. Almost none share it. The work continues. The clinician sees a full clinic the next day and goes home carrying something unspoken.
No leader decided, “We won’t talk about this.” It just never comes up.
But silence that no one chose is still a choice. It becomes an unwritten policy.
Item Number One
Years ago, I worked at a VA hospital. By the time I arrived, the chief of mental health had been running the department for about six years.
He had a rule: whenever the department learned a patient had died by suicide, the case was reviewed and then shared with the whole department at the staff meeting.
At my first staff meeting, he opened the meeting himself. The suicide review was the first item on the agenda.
Not the last item. Not “if we have time.” First.
I had never seen anything like it.
He or his deputy presented the case. The clinicians who treated the patient were not required to say anything. The delivery was direct, focusing only on the facts:
When was the patient last seen?
Did the note from that visit show any sign of risk?
Has someone from the hospital spoken with the family?
That was it. No drama. No hush. Nobody asked, “What should you have done differently?”
Plain facts, said out loud, by the person in charge. That was the whole trick.
I never saw anyone get defensive. I don’t think anyone felt they had to.
It Didn’t Change Our Practice. It Changed Something Else.
Here’s what surprised me.
Those reviews didn’t change how we assessed risk. Most of us already followed best practices. If you were looking for a change in practice, most of the time you wouldn’t have found one.
What changed was the people.
We spoke openly about patient suicide. When a colleague lost a patient, others noticed. I saw people make an effort to check on clinicians whose patients had died.
I never lost a patient to suicide while I worked there. But I knew that if it happened, I wouldn’t carry it alone.
Doctors are trained to discuss bad outcomes for one reason: to fix something. Surgeons have Morbidity and Mortality conferences to find errors and change processes.
So when nothing went wrong clinically, we think there’s nothing to discuss.
That chief understood something most of us don’t learn:
Not every hard conversation is there to fix something. Some are there so nobody carries it alone.
Three Moves You Can Steal
You don’t have to run a psychiatry department to use this idea. And the lesson here is not only about suicide.
Every field has an outcome nobody talks about. A patient or customer complaint that turned ugly. A missed diagnosis. A death on the table. A colleague who quit after a terrible experience.
Here’s what that chief did — and what any leader can do.
1. Put it first. Where you put something on the agenda tells people how much it matters. Hard things at the end get skipped. Hard things at the top get faced.
2. Say it yourself. When the leader presents, the leader carries the weight. No one else has to stand up to explain one of the worst moments of their career to a room full of peers.
3. Stick to the facts. Calm, plain facts show that this happens in our work and we deal with it together. Drama makes it a tragedy. Judgment makes it a trial. Facts make it something we share.
The Times obituary desk seems to have learned this lesson over time. Hiding the truth hurts. Sensationalizing also hurts. Telling the plain truth with care is better.
The Part Nobody Tells You
Here’s the harder truth.
When I walked into that first meeting, trust was already present in the room. It took six years to build, with dozens of meetings and many times when people saw a bad outcome named, and no one got hurt.
If you start this tomorrow, your first meeting won’t feel like mine. People may brace themselves. Someone might get defensive. You might wonder if you made a mistake.
You didn’t make a mistake. You just started the clock.
I’ve worked in other places since. I’ve never seen this again.
So many of us still lead departments, divisions, or teams where silence about hard things is the unwritten policy. Not because we chose it, but because we never chose another way.
The One Practice
The next time your team faces a bad outcome, make it the first item on your next meeting’s agenda.
Present it yourself. Share only the facts: what happened, when it happened, and what has been done for those affected.
Then close with one question: “Who needs support right now, and who’s going to check on them?”
Then watch how the room changes. Not just that day, but over the next year.
If you or someone you know is struggling, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.



